The president gave the network until Friday to act on Trump’s complaint about part of the film Trump: A second chance? Through our long-running current affairs series panorama.
The film was broadcast days before the 2024 US elections, and included excerpts of a speech Trump gave to his supporters on January 6, 2021 before thousands of them headed to the US Capitol to try to prevent the certification of the election results.
He – she You swear Together three quotes from two sections of the speech delivered about 50 minutes apart make it appear that Trump urged his supporters to march with him to the Capitol and called for violence.
Trump is shown saying in the edited footage: “We will march to the Capitol… and I will be there with you… and fight. Fight like hell.”
In the unedited quote, Trump said: “We’re going to march to the Capitol, and we’re going to be cheering on our brave senators and congresswomen and women, and maybe not even cheering so much for some of them.”
BBC Chairman Samir Shah said the network’s standards committee discussed editing the clips earlier this year and expressed its concerns to the channel. panorama a team. The film is no longer available online at BBCWebsite for.
“The uproar over the Trump documentary is not about journalistic integrity. It is a power play… It is a war over words, in which the very vocabulary of journalism is used as a weapon.”
“We accept that the way the letter was edited gave the impression of a direct call for violent action,” Shah said. “the BBC “I would like to apologize for this error in judgement.”
Two senior executives, managing director Tim Davie and head of news Deborah Turness, also resigned on Sunday under pressure over the documentary.
The uproar comes days after the rise of the right Daily Telegraph Details published from a note written by the former BBC Standards Committee adviser Michael Prescott, “managing director at PR agency Hanover Communications, whose staff went on to work for the Conservative Party”. according to Novara Media.
Prescott’s memo targeted the documentary as well as what he claimed was pro-trans bias BBC News coverage and anti-Israel bias in stories he wrote BBCArabic service.
according to the GuardianRobbie Gibb, member of BBC The board, which previously served as communications officer for former Tory Prime Minister Theresa May, “amplified” criticisms in Prescott’s memo at key board meetings before Davie and Torness resigned.
Delivery time I mentioned Monday that “insiders” in BBC They claimed that Prescott’s memo, the resignations and Trump’s threat of legal action all stem from an attempted right-wing “coup” against the broadcaster.
Journalists, including Mehdi Hassan Zetio News and Mickey Smith to woman He pointed out that while panoramaTrump’s editing of Trump’s speech may be seen as misleading, and the documentary was not responsible for accusations that the president incited violence on January 6, which preceded the film.
“To understand how crazy that is BBC They are accused of “making it look like” Trump was inciting violence with his bad edit, as opposed to Trump actually inciting violence, and we even know His children “That day we were desperately trying to convince him to call off the mob.” He said Good.
Others suggested that the memo mentioned in Trump’s letter to the broadcaster should be discredited entirely because of its claim that… BBC showed bias against Israel, which is an allegation, He said Author and international relations professor Norrie MacEwen, it was “a whole new level” of “news language” for George Orwell.
while BBC “She was shaken by one of her smallest sins,” media analyst Faisal Hanif wrote on Twitter. Eye of the Middle East“The biggest matter, namely his distortion of the Palestinian reality, goes unpunished.”
Hanif referred to a report published In June by the Media Monitoring Center, which showed that although Gaza has suffered 34 times more heavy casualties than Israel since October 2023, BBC “Israeli Obituaries gave 33 times more coverage per death and ran roughly equal numbers of humanitarian casualty profiles (279 Palestinians vs. 201 Israelis).”
The network also used “four times more emotive terms for Israeli victims” and shut down allegations that Israel committed genocide in Gaza, as well as “never referring to Israeli leaders’ statements on genocide,” even as Israel faces a genocide case at the International Court of Justice.
“The uproar over the Trump documentary is not about journalistic integrity,” Hanif wrote. “It is a power play: disciplining a public broadcaster that still nominally answers to the public rather than to billionaire-owned media. It is a war on words, in which the very vocabulary of journalism is weaponised.”
“the BBC Punished for wrong things. Hanif continued: “It is losing its leaders due to a editorial error, while escaping accountability for its editorial failures in Gaza.” He added: “The Trump documentary may have been edited wrongly, but the Gaza story has been distorted for much longer.” if BBC She still believes in her own motto – “Nation shall speak peace to nation” – that peace must begin with honesty.
Source link
